Upper Crust Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Upper Crust Pizza invites pizza lovers to explore a diverse menu brimming with flavors. Signature selections like the Seafood Pizza and Homemade Meat Lasagna shine alongside fan favorites such as Gooey Homemade Garlic Bread and delicious Chicken Wings. The extensive offering includes 101 dishes ranging from hearty subs to fresh salads, catering to every palate. For the sweet tooth, don’t miss the Homemade Key Lime Pie—a local delight. With average prices around $15.87, it's perfect for family dining or a casual night out. Come for the fresh ingredients and stay for the unbeatable flavors.

The build-your-own pizza option lets diners customize their 12” delight, while the craft beer pairs beautifully with your meal. Upper Crust Pizza's menu promises to satisfy, combining classic comfort with local flair.

Appetizers / Side Orders
Chicken Wings 6
Salads
Subs
Whole Wheat Sandwiches
Dinners
Desserts
House Specialty Pizzas *prices for 12"
Build Your Own Pizza
Soft Drinks

Featured Dishes

Homemade Chef's Garlic Rolls 12
Homemade Chef's Garlic Rolls 12
Upper Crust Pizza
Upper Crust Pizza
Chicken Wings 12
Chicken Wings 12
Meatlovers Pizza
Meatlovers Pizza
Chimay
Chimay
Stromboli
Stromboli
Calzone
Calzone
Meatballs
Meatballs
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Peppers
Peppers
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Coffee
Coffee
Hawaiian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Salami
Salami
Crazy Lady IPA by Beautiful Martina
Crazy Lady IPA by Beautiful Martina
Napkins and Sugar
Napkins and Sugar
Lasagne
Lasagne
Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Seafood Pizza and Princess Pizza
Seafood Pizza and Princess Pizza
Thin Crust Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Thin Crust Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Upper Crust Pizza Menu image 1
Upper Crust Pizza Menu image 2
Upper Crust Pizza Menu image 3
Upper Crust Pizza Menu image 4
Upper Crust Pizza

Upper Crust Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Upper Crust Pizza is like stepping into a local hub of warmth and flavor. The casual yet inviting ambiance makes it an ideal spot for families, friends, or a laid-back date. Wooden accents and charming decor create a welcoming environment, perfect for enjoying a hearty meal after a day of exploring the Florida keys. The open layout fosters a community feel, encouraging laughter and conversation among patrons.

The openness allows the tantalizing aroma of fresh pizza and baked goods to fill the space, setting the stage for a mouthwatering experience.

Whether you sit at the bar to sample craft beers or cozy up in a booth to dive into a shrimp pizza, Upper Crust Pizza embraces the spirit of community dining. Each visit provides a chance to savor delicious food in a lively atmosphere dedicated to good times.

Upper Crust Pizza

About Upper Crust Pizza Food and Specialties

The food at Upper Crust Pizza speaks to both tradition and creativity. Known for its homemade dishes, the restaurant highlights fresh ingredients sourced locally. The Garlic Rolls, perfect for sharing, embody the comforting essence of Italian cuisine. Meanwhile, the Seafood Pizza offers a taste of Florida's maritime bounty, featuring shrimp and fresh catches. Each dish balances flavor and quality while remaining approachable in price.

Diners often rave about the Alfredo and the variety of chicken wings, available in multiple flavors. There’s a unique charm in enjoying a satisfying meal amidst the vibrant atmosphere of Key Largo. Upper Crust Pizza transforms classic recipes and local ingredients into memorable culinary experiences for everyone, whether you’re dining in or taking away.

Upper Crust Pizza

Upper Crust Pizza remains steadfast in its commitment to quality and community. The restaurant focuses on using fresh ingredients, ensuring that every dish bursts with flavor. The specialty pizzas highlight local seafood, catching the eye of both newcomers and locals. A dedication to customer satisfaction drives the staff to provide warm, welcoming service—not just in their cuisine, but also in hospitality. The vision here goes beyond serving food; it aims to foster a vibrant gathering place where people connect over shared meals. This approach has garnered a loyal following and a significant place in the hearts of Key Largo residents.